NTR Crush: I Will Steal Every Girl

I ended up spending most of Friday talking with Mary. She was surprisingly easy to get along with. She was beautiful, had a cute side and a mischievous side, and she had a beautiful laugh. Deep into the evening, we ended up walking along the beach. As for what we talked about, it was all kinds of things. Where did we see our future? What were our interests? These were things I didn’t even know about my own girlfriend. Yet, Mary had a fascinating life.

“Do you have a boyfriend of your own?” I found myself asking as we continued to walk, listening to the waves hit the shore.

She lowered her head, a weak smile on her face. “I do.”

I felt my heart drop a bit. I knew it wasn’t fair. I had two girls I was fighting over, and I talked about them a lot of the night. She hadn’t mentioned her own dating at all, though. I didn’t have the right to feel angry about it, but a part of me wanted to monopolize her.

“You haven’t mentioned him.”

“He hasn’t been around much in my life.” She said, a frown forming on her face.

“I’m sorry if you don’t want to talk about it…”

“No, it’s fine.” She reached out and grabbed my arm. “I don’t want to keep anything from you. You’ve been so honest with me.”

“Ah…” I smiled awkwardly, knowing even with her I wasn’t completely honest.

“When my relationship with him started, I thought it would last forever, you know? But his eyes always wandered toward other women. One, in particular, she was a vindictive girl who liked to steal guys from other women.”

“S-seriously?”

She nodded seriously. “Yeah, she didn’t even like the men. She had no desire to keep them. She just wanted to play. After she was done playing, she’d runoff. Relationships are hard, Hakaru. They require effort. She was easy… and flighty… and that appeals to a lot of men.”

“Wow… that sounds really bad.”

“I’m not beyond guilt either. I… used my popularity to suppress her, and I clung to my boyfriend too hard, afraid to let him leave. However, recently, I’ve started to realize that it was wrong. Nothing lasts forever, and people change.”

“What are you saying?”

She stopped and turned to me. I realized that my hands were in hers. I felt my heart beating faster as she looked at me with a smile.

“I don’t love him anymore.”

I started to feel a glimmer of hope. “Then, shouldn’t you break it off with him?”

She gave a weak smile. “I’m… afraid. I don’t want to be alone.”

“Why are you telling me this?”

She reached up and wiped a tear from her cheek, taking a breath. “Ah… sorry… I just wanted you to understand me. You’re cute, and I like you.”

“I… like you too.”

With her eyes just faintly teary, and having just told me personal things about herself, Mary was coming off as extremely appealing. She looked beautiful in the light of the sunset, and she was looking at me with a lost look that made me want to hold her and make all of her worries go away. I found my arms wrapping around her delicate form. Mary leaned against me, her head falling to my chest. After holding each other like that for a few moments, she looked up, her lips full of color and inviting.

We started moving toward each other, about to kiss, but just at the last second, she turned away. “I’m sorry, I can’t…”

“That’s… I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have pushed.” I apologized back.

“No… it’s fine. It’s okay to push a little.” She laughed nervously. “I do mean it… I really like you, Hakaru.”

“I have a girlfriend… and even that’s a mess. You have a boyfriend.”

“We… could leave them. We could just have each other…” She suggested quietly.

“I don’t know what I want in life. What if I cheat?”

“If you cheat… then I’ll do better.” She responded, her hands tightening on my arms. “I’ll make you happy where I couldn’t manage with him.”

I lifted an arm and stroked a strand of hair out of her eyes. “Come on. It’s getting late.”

We headed to the road and took a bus, holding hands the entire way. Every time I looked back at her, she’d blush cutely. She really was a fun and interesting girl.

“When can we meet again?” I asked as I started taking her back to her place.”

“Hm… maybe Wednesday night?”

“Are you sure you’re okay with that?”

She smiled. “Mm!’

She got off at her stop in front of a gated community of apartments. She said that it was impossible to bring a stranger into her house so late at night. It was a shame, but also good as well. I didn’t want to rush things with her. On the other hand, I seemed to remember my first two girlfriends becoming a disaster because I didn’t push things. Maybe I should be a little more forceful with her?

I shook my head. No, I was dating Kira. It was Kira I should be forceful with. I had slept with Akiko, but I still hadn’t been with my own girlfriend. If that wasn’t an ample opportunity for her to leave me, then I don’t know what was. I absolutely had to set up a time and get with Kira. Pulling out my phone, I sent her a text. I asked her if she was available to hang out tomorrow.

This was the first message I had sent since the awkward date the night before. She responded immediately that it was fine. We agreed to meet at her place. In my mind, I was already preparing to have sex with her. Damn… was there something wrong with me? After having such a time with Mary, my immediate inclination was to go bone my girlfriend. Is it because I didn’t want to feel like I was cheating? Or because I felt horny after spending all day on a somewhat platonic date.

It wasn’t even really a date in the first place! It was just two acquaintances hanging out. We didn’t even do anything! Kira was my girlfriend. She was the girl I was going to have tomorrow. There was no point in dwelling on it much longer.

By the time I finished the conversation over the phone and set up the time I’d stop over, The bus was pulling to the stop near my house. The sun had already set, and it was dark outside now. It was just the right time to get home without getting yelled at. I noticed that dad’s car was gone. When I entered the house, it was dark, so my immediate assumption was that mom and dad were out.

That was nice. Mom and dad deserved some time out together. That thought suddenly felt off and inappropriate. A sudden memory of her declaring she didn’t love him and wanted me instead appeared in my mind. I shook my head, refusing to accept those weird thoughts. Mom was just drunk and saying random stuff. Why did I feel like her relationship with dad was in a bad place? It didn’t matter. I had my own problems to worry about.

Getting myself a Ramune from the fridge, I headed into my room. Taking a drink and putting it on the nightstand, I lay down in bed and closed my eyes. Just as I was about to slip off to sleep, I heard a sound of my door shutting. I opened my eyes into the darkness. I realized there was a form standing in my doorway. I went for my light, but before I could get my fingers on it, the person had jumped on me. In shock, I barely fought back as they grabbed my hands and tied them to the headboard.

The other reason I didn’t fight back as they did this was that I could see bare naked flesh. They had a robe on, but it was undone, and it revealed the beautiful porcelain skin of a woman. She had a scarf wrapped around her head, hiding her face, but she was undeniably a naked woman. My mind started to run through. She wasn’t curvy enough to be my mother. Maybe she was Kira? No, the tits were too small. Akiko? Why would Akiko break into my bed and tie me to the bed? Why would anyone break into my room and tie me to the bed?

That answer came a moment later when I felt my pants being fiddled with. Cool, soft hands ended up grabbing my dick and pulling it out. Gripping the shaft, she started to rub it against her own, hot genitals. The feeling left me completely shocked. I still barely could grasp what was going on, but my body reacted accordingly, and I grew hard. The woman slid it inside her crotch, and I let out a moan.

My sister next door wasn’t playing loud music. If I just yelled, I could probably get her attention, but I was completely frozen as I watched the mysterious figure start to rock her hips and ride my cock. She was moving with a need and desperation that caused my brain to turn numb and my body to feel aroused. After already having a date with a few hot and bothered moments that came to nothing, this level of eroticism was out of the world.

I had no clue who the woman on top of me was. Her body was perfect, but I couldn’t place it against a face at all. This couldn’t be Mary, could it?

“Mar-“ She suddenly put her hand over my mouth, as if afraid I’d finish that name.

It had clearly caught her off guard. It really was Mary? I was reaching out completely when I had that thought, but she had all but confirmed it, hadn’t she? So, she was unwilling to cheat openly on her boyfriend, but she would sneak into my house at night and have her way with me? This was all too strange, but then again, I was the one being tied to the bed.

“I’ve really been wanting this.” I panted, deciding to enjoy Mary’s tight pussy to its fullest.

Her body shuddered for a second, and then she reached out and touched my chest affectionately. She then put her palms on my chest and used them to push up and down faster and faster, riding my cock for all it was worth. The bed even squeaked a bit. Seeing as Maria used to have sex all the time late at night in her room, it only served her right if she had to listen to me doing it with someone. As for mom and dad, I wouldn’t be as unconcerned if I believed they were home.

I let my moans and pants fill the room, although if I made a noise too loud, she’d cutely freak out and try to cover my mouth. I really wanted to kiss her, but she seemed content to hide her body, even though I had already figured out who it was. Her skin was pale, her body was skinny, with two lumps for breasts, it was really obvious now that I thought about it.

“Ah… I’m cumming. I’m going to cum in you Mary,” I moaned, she put her hand over my mouth again, and I playfully bit her palm.

Her body started to shudder, and I could feel her climaxing over my dick. At that point, I had also reached my end. I ended up unloading my cum deep inside Mary. Well, it wasn’t like I could stop if I wanted to. She had me tied down.

As I came, I looked up at her. “I love you…”

I didn’t know if that’s how I actually felt. In truth, I barely knew her. However, after such an incredible date, the words came out. Perhaps, I was a romantic and a bit of an idiot, but I couldn’t help myself.

Her body finished spasming, and she fell down on my chest. The pair of us remained like that, panting and sharing body warmth as my cock slowly softened insider her pussy. She reached her arms around me and gave me a hug.

“I love you too, brother.” She murmured.

With that, she stood up, and grabbing her robe, fled the room without even bothering to untie my restraints. However, I was frozen on the spot from the moment she hugged me. Only when the door behind her closed did I finally manage to speak.

“B-brother?”

Not Mary, Maria! My sister? My sister just raped me! She tied me to a bed and fucked me! I came in my sister!

“Oh… shit!”

Things were getting even more complicated.